Great films of the past should be left alone. Contemporary remakes, sequels, or films merely set in the same universe are unlikely to enhance the reputations of classics. On the contrary, fans of the originals are most likely to be sorely disappointed with the quality of new films. This explains what happened to Soldier, a 1998 science fiction film directed by Paul W.S. Anderson.
The plot of the film begins with a soldier known only as Sergeant Todd (played by Kurt Russell). In his earliest childhood, he was selected for a brutal training program and later conditioned to become a cold and efficient killing machine. In the year 2036 A.D., despite showing his murderous ability in numerous wars and campaigns, Todd is considered obsolete by Colonel Mekum (played by Jason Isaacs). He is to be replaced with a new breed of genetically engineered soldiers like Caine 607 (played by Jason Scott Lee). After losing a test fight with Caine, Todd is left for dead and tossed into Arcadia, a desolate planet where he is rescued by a group of shipwrecks who had created their little utopia. Todd, housed by the colony's elder Mace (played by Sean Pertwee) and his wife Sandra (played by Connie Nielsen), slowly begins to develop human emotions and befriends the couple's autistic son. But when Mekum decides to use Arcadia as a test ground for his new soldiers, Todd must use his abilities again, this time to save the colonists.
According to scriptwriter David Webb Peoples, Soldier was supposed to be set in the same universe as the legendary Blade Runner. However, fans of the 1982 classic were disappointed to hear about the script being changed and director Paul W.S. Anderson insisting on Soldier as nothing more than a futuristic remake of Shane. After that, Soldier was savaged by critics, but it is actually a much better film than its reputation would indicate. The beginning, which features the brutal conditioning of young children, is wonderfully staged, and many science fiction fans would be reminded of Orson Scott Card's classic novel Ender's Game. Throughout the film, Anderson pays great attention to production design, costumes, and special effects. Kurt Russell is also very convincing in the role of the quiet warrior who slowly discovers his humanity. However, these qualities aren't enough to compensate for the serious script flaws. For example, the film doesn't explain why anyone would bother to travel through light-years of space only to dump tons of trash on remote planets. Soldier is also burdened with clichés - the fate of Mace is easy to predict when his wife starts becoming close with the protagonist, the villain is over the top, and the ending features an all-too-familiar one-on-one combat. Joel McNeely's music is also quite disappointing. Soldier didn't deserve to be treated so harshly by critics, but it also didn't deserve recommendations.
RATING: 4/10 (+)
(Note: The text in its original form was posted in the Usenet newsgroup rec.arts.films.reviews on June 24th, 2004)
Blog in Croatian: draxblog
Blog in English: draxreview
Rising Star game: Join now
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7