The steady stream of Hollywood remakes in the past few years is often attributed to the apparent lack of creativity among the pillars of the American film industry. However, there are some remakes that simply defy explanation. One of them is In Cold Blood, a 1996 TV film/miniseries directed by Jonathan Kaplan. Based on the Pulitzer Prize-winning book by Truman Capote, this adaptation of the classic 1967 Hollywood docudrama leaves much to be desired.
The film opens in 1959 Kansas, where Doug Hickok (played by Anthony Edwards) and Perry Smith (played by Eric Roberts), two ex-convicts who formed a bond behind bars, roam the streets living off petty thefts and forged checks. When they catch wind of a rich farmer, Herb Clutter (played by Kevin Thighe), and a rumored safe filled with money on his farm, they see it as an opportunity for a big score. Breaking into the Clutter's home one night, they demand money, only to discover that the safe is empty. In a desperate attempt to avoid identification, Hickok and Smith brutally murder Clutter, his wife, and their two children. The shock of the crime reverberates throughout the nation, prompting Kansas detective Dewey (played by Sam Neill), a close friend of the Clutters, to relentlessly pursue the killers. Despite fleeing to Mexico, Hickok and Smith eventually return due to financial constraints.
Fans of "true crime" docudramas are drawn to the genre for its authentic portrayal of real-life events. The 1967 version of In Cold Blood was lauded for its authenticity, with scenes shot on location and real-life figures participating in the reenactments. Unfortunately, Kaplan's 1996 TV adaptation falls short in comparison, lacking the same level of authenticity. The use of color and unconventional casting choices are the only highlights, with Anthony Edwards stepping out of his usual nice-guy roles to portray a homicidal character and Eric Roberts attempting to humanize one of the killers. However, the director's detachment from the material is evident, resulting in lackluster performances from the cast. For those familiar with the book, this version of In Cold Blood may come across as a disappointing and unnecessary retelling of an excellent story.
Rating: 2/10 (-)
Originally posted on Usenet newsgroup rec.arts.films.reviews on April 12, 2004
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7