In Search of Education

in education •  3 years ago 

I have taught, on and off, for many years, so seems obvious I would also teach my own kid. I mean, why would I leave that to other teachers? The granulated curricula, served in handy sachets (add sugar to taste), created by ministries of indoctrination are not exactly inspiring.

And so, here we are, once again, taking responsibility for our own children - astonishing. I have met many parents who think they are paying for a private education precisely to absolve themselves of their own responsibilities as teachers. School is a nanny service with benefits; teachers are doubleplus-nannies.

The best teachers can see the mess and turn desiccated ingredients into a palatable and nutritious meal. Many others don't seem to understand that sucking on dry rice is not a valuable experience. So many new teachers have bought into the propaganda. They pretend to teach "higher order skills" while their kids are drowning in illiteracy and innumeracy. Flapping your arms does not make you fly.

So, let's start with a clean slate. A good definition of a professional - whatever the profession may be - is someone who carries around within them a large network of knowledge and experiences that can be called upon to make some judgment on new situations.

This requires a certain amount of factual knowledge, but more importantly, it requires the skills needed to acquire new knowledge and to process it within the existing framework. This is not rote learning; this is learning how to process.

Rote learning does have its place but it is limited to very basic knowledge. Try reading without knowing the alphabet. A lot of our rote learning took place in our early years that we have forgotten both its value and its limitations. Most of us know how not to fall over when we walk - that took years of practice. Learning to ride a bicycle also took practice. In both cases, that knowledge is not really at the conscious level; we have trained our muscles and nervous system to acquire a kinetic-memory that is hard to unlearn - try falling off a bike on purpose.

So, designing an educational journey requires going back to some very basic knowledge, then building outwards from that. Not all of it is intellectual knowledge - far from it - as so much of it is somatic or kinetic in nature, be it learning to play the violin, kicking a ball or milking a cow. However, all those activities require a real violin, a real ball... and a real cow. None of which I can teleport to you, and virtual reality is a con job; the body knows it is being fooled.

Although I can write about any topic under the sun, just through the medium of language, those physical skills require one to step away from the computer and go do them. I can certainly write about them but that is no substitute for actually doing them.

Where shall we start?

Firstly, I think every growing child requires three languages: English, mathematics and computer code.

Obviously either add your own language or replace the English. The latter will, however, make everything I write hard to understand.

Added to these basic skills are:

learning how to learn;

thinking about how to think;

and, knowing how to know.

These may be better known as memory, logic and science.

The classical Liberal Arts (seemingly eviscerated from so-called Liberal Arts Colleges) were the linguistic trivium of grammar, logic and rhetoric, plus the quadrivium of arithmetic, geometry, astronomy and music - yes, the mathematics of music! This was the basis of a classical intellectual education; if you wanted to actually do anything you'd probably end up in a trade school or guild and learn your craft there. We haven't move very far from this scheme.

The final ingredient is... fun! I know, I always cringe at the word when it comes out of the mouth of a teacher. But children are learning new things all the time - it is fun for them, so long as everything remains new and interesting. It really makes no difference if one kid is reading Dickens, another kid is learning to code sequences and yet another kid is playing with his snot - I mean, playing the piano. So that "fun" is not so much an ingredient, but rather the joy of eating.

Education is much like cooking; you can follow a recipe, but when you understand what each ingredient does then you can be creative.

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE BLURT!
Sort Order:  
  ·  3 years ago  ·  

In search of education ?
https://www.minds.com/thehonestteacher/

tHT.JPG

;-)

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

John Taylor Gatto had a few words to say on those ;-)

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

In your professional opinion as a teacher, what do you think of Waldorf school systems?

There is 1 near me, just 1 within 1000 kms, when i looked into it, it seems like after you self pace through math, science and the basics of grammar, they specialize you into a trade around the grade 6 year in other schools. Even if they kid doesnt like the trade they picked as an adult, the school could arguably continue their education.

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

I have known a few people who attended Waldorf schools. Great for early years but IMO sorely lacking in hard scientific skills and mathematics.

What I find interesting are Krishnamurti schools - I think only 3 in the whole world! sadly, coz from what I've seen, he got it right - combining internal and external sciences, or self-knowledge and world-knowledge.

If I had a school, it would most resemble Krishnamurti's :-)
and that also requires very good teachers!

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

Even if they kid doesnt like the trade they picked as an adult, the school could arguably continue their education.

I don't understand that bit - they take adult students too now?

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

I was wondering if they had post secondary Waldorf but i doubt it, and I have only read an advertisement. Its cool to hear someone else has actually heard of this, but i like the sounds of the Krishnamurti better, what country is he from?

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

If you've never heard of him, his is a truly bizarre story...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jiddu_Krishnamurti
I'm astonished he ended up so sane!
schools: https://jkrishnamurti.org/schools

Once you know the context, this speech is great: https://jkrishnamurti.org/about-dissolution-speech
The "messiah" tells the faithful to bugger off!
lmao

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

If we're looking at alt-ed systems, you may also be interested in the Reggio Emilia approach: https://www.reggiochildren.it/en/reggio-emilia-approach/
Philosophically related to psychodynamics and social constructivism.

Again, my feeling is that it is a more humane approach, but somehow lacks an edge! Also is dedicated to early years.

Somehow, the transformation from human child to worker robot has not been figured out in the transition from primary to secondary ed!

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

Thinking now... that's what the Krishnamurti schools get right - the transition from human child to human adult :-)

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

Experience is the best teacher.
keep learning anytime and anywhere. because knowledge is everywhere..

we have trained our muscles and nervous system to acquire a kinetic-memory that is hard to unlearn - try falling off a bike on purpose.

This made me laugh. In one of the martial arts I took emphasis is placed heavily on falling. I remember the difficulties in fighting my reflexes from trying to stop me. Stopping as we are taught and flowing as they were teaching were at odds with one another in my muscle memories.

A well constructed critique/examination on what exists opposed to what is needed. School is so impersonal (on purpose) and boring many children dismiss it as they neither see how it's important nor how they fit into the scheme of what's presented.

Critical thinking is not only neglected in most school curriculum, it is discouraged and punished. Such an approach not only forces an atrophy to take place, but forces an agreement one is not worthy of such pursuit.

I mentioned to you before on my homeschooling my own child after 5th grade. While there are many who probably would have been better suited for such an endeavor, they were not found at the state run so called learning institutions. Those are little more than propaganda factories for many years now.

I really appreciate the last part you mention about having fun. I've said for many years that after watching so many people it became obvious that even those who most regard as idiots are quite often geniuses at the things that interest them. Years ago when I first realized this it made me sad, thinking of how much more quality could exist in the world if we took into account the childs natural interests and skills and built an educational model structured around that.

Welcome back, I hope you were able to accomplish what you needed to do.

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

haha - as I wrote that I was thinking of counter-examples eg stuntmen, drunk kung fu - all of them then require practice to unlearn what we have learnt over many years.

I say this with no pleasure, to see "know thyself" become "promote thyself", to see the observer turn into narcissist, both observe but only one is entranced, and hence disempowered.

I still find it interesting that not everybody has bought into the fakeworld. But if we don't actually fight, we will be sent to the gulags soon enough, or a ghetto will be built around us, as is happening online.

eg schools here now turning into real prisons - else they won't be allowed to re-open.

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

Superb bro.

Congratulations, your post has been upvoted by @r2cornell, which is the curating account for @R2cornell's Discord Community.

Curated by <@bestkizito >

r2cornell_curation_banner.png

  ·  3 years ago  ·  

Excellent post, matey !